How to navigate the new emission laws

The closer we get to small engine emissions standards, the uglier it looks. While the Minister tells us that we are modelling ourselves on the world’s best standards, we are heading for something far inferior.

Oh sure, the exhaust “pass” mark will look the same as the USEPA, but with too many loopholes we may end up with the Swiss cheese laws they had in Europe, which EUROMOT tells us resulted in 42 per cent noncompliance – mostly the “cheap and cheerful” products.

A responsible Industry ought to be terrified by the prospect of the market flooded with cheap, disposable garden equipment, while Industry works with one hand tied behind our back – and only able to sell compliant clean products.

What are the loopholes? Well I’m not going to share all of them – just in case I decide to turn rogue and make my fortune selling contraband.

LOOPHOLE #1 – IMPORT VIA NEW ZEALAND
It’s not as if Australia’s Border Force (aka Customs) has a blind spot when it comes to imports coming across the Tasman. They have their hands tied by government – in fact it’s called the Commonwealth Mutual Recognition Act 1992 and the Trans-Tasman Mutual Recognition Act 1997. Under the trade agreements with NZ, goods that can be legally sold in New Zealand, can be imported from NZ and sold freely in Australia (and vice versa of course).

This loophole is usually closed by the Kiwi’s passing similar legislation and standards. We’ve checked. NZ doesn’t have small engine emissions standards and they are not even on the drawing board. That means that you can import anything you like into Australia – if you ship it via the Port of Taurunga.

We know that some companies are already abusing this loophole to import products that don’t meet Australian safety standards.

Don’t bank on making your fortune in NZ dollars. Our Environment Department has been aware of this loophole forever. I first read about it in the 2007 report on small engine emissions.

I have spoken to the team in Canberra and they are working on closing this loophole by applying for an exemption to the Trans Tasman Treaty. It’s a long process and they have completed the first few steps: getting approval to apply and getting the response from the New Zealand government who have no emissions laws and no plans to start any time soon. It won’t be wrapped up in a hurry. They have until the start date of 1 July 2018, and are very busy getting the Australian laws and rules ready.

So, while there is a loophole today, expect it to be closed before the laws commence.

LOOPHOLE #2 – EXEMPTIONS
Need to import fifty dirty engines for racing competitions? Easy! Just fill in this form and you are all set. No proof needed. So who will check?
In serious jurisdictions racing engines are allowed, but they are restricted to buyers with competition licences, for use in practice and competitions only, and can only be resold to the importer or another licenced competitor. Australia may not have any of those sensible controls. That’s just one of many exemptions planned (can you hear my heavy sigh?).

LOOPHOLE #3 – SELL ON EBAY
Selling on eBay is no longer just for garage cleanouts and shonky importers. Major retailers like Myer and the Good Guys have a significant sized business on eBay. OK, ok, yes, it’s still full of shonky importers.
I just checked and found 1,281 listings for new petrol, push behind mowers on eBay. Some of them are imports and for under $300. Not only cheap, but imports under $1,000 avoid paying GST any import Duty that you and I have to pay in our businesses. These imports won’t be stopped at the border because we are getting desk inspections not physical checks at Customs. When I told the department that this isn’t good enough enforcement they replied that they would talk to eBay to get them to delist such products. That makes eBay the “policeman” and the expert to determine if a mower meets USA EPA standards or not. How is that even possible let alone realistic?

But any rogue can get around eBay by building their own online shop. Kogan, for example, is a Melbourne based company that sells $211m per annum worth of televisions, drones, push behind mowers and brushcutters. Yet they import few products – many are in fact sold by Kogan Hong Kong and it’s the consumer who is actually the importer on record.

LOOPHOLES #4 THROUGH #11
Sorry, but I’ve run out of space to explain even more loopholes. Some are small fish and will get a few machines into the country without risking a fine. On top of that there are a range of “cheats” that dodgy importers will abuse. One of these cheats was being used to import air conditioners, and I first heard it explained in 2007 by the then Environment Minister, Malcolm Turnbull. Basically fake certification, but I won’t publish how to do it.

Why the heck am I publicizing all these ways for responsible businesses to get creamed by the new laws?

Well I’m as mad as hell and I’m not going to take this anymore! Eleven years I have been doing my best to see that we have standards that will protect both Australians and industry. Now at the last minute, bureaucrats are installing a system that is so weak that all it can protect is their shiny butt. It just isn’t good enough. In fact, we could end up with more air pollution. The cheap and cheerful replica engines produce two or three times the emissions of the “genuine” carby two strokes. So, when the genuine importers follow the law and enough shonky importers flaunt the loopholes we get an increase in pollution.

It’s not over. The responsible members of this industry have a lot of work to do and that needs to start now, today, and not when sales plummet in Q4 2018.

If you are as mad as hell too, let’s have a chat about it at the OPEA AGM in Melbourne, August 11th, where I will be making a presentation on just this topic.

GARY FOOKS
Gary Fooks is Chair of the Blue Sky Alliance: a collaboration between the OPEA and the marine engine sector. Gary has been working on small engine emissions standards since 2005 and was announced as the Environment Minister’s Clean Air Champion in 2015.